Concha’s family demands DNA testing; remains presented ‘unidentifiable’
The Communist Party of the Philippines (CPP) said the family of National Democratic Front of the Philippines (NDFP) peace consultant Maria Coronacion Araneta-Bocala has requested deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) testing to determine if the remains presented by the military were really hers.
Following claims by the Philippine Army that Araneta-Bocala was among those killed in a series of armed encounters in Calinog, Iloilo since August 8, the CPP accused the Armed Forces of the Philippines (AFP) of desecrating the remains of the victims.
“The family of Ka Concha (Araneta-Bocala)…have requested DNA testing to ascertain whether the remains are hers, as it was impossible to make an identification through visual inspection,” CPP chief information officer Marco Valbuena said.
Valbuena also said they have been informed that the family of Rewilmar Torrato has confirmed the identity of her remains.
Valbuena added that the supposed remains of Vicente Hinojales have yet to be examined “because these have yet to be taken out of the ‘garbage bag.’”
“The manner with which the remains have been handled, and how families are being given a hard time, harassed and intimidated by the AFP, speak of their low regard for international humanitarian law (IHL), which specifies how remains of fallen combatants should be handled with dignity and respect,” Valbuena said.
The AFP said Bocala-Araneta, Torrato and Hinojales are among the top leaders of the revolutionary movement in Panay Island.
Araneta-Bocala and Teodosio were reportedly killed following a 10-minute fire fight with troops from the 82nd Infantry Battalion in Barangay Cabatangan, Lambunao last August 15 while Hinojales may have been killed as early as August 5 by units under the 3rd Infantry Division of the AFP.
Earlier, the AFP reported it killed five NPA fighters last August 8 in Calinog.
Rules of war violations
Human rights group Karapatan-Panay in a statement Sunday condemned the AFP for taking a long time in releasing some remains of NPA fighters to their respective families.
“It took days for the families to finally obtain the remains – which were also in various stages of decomposition – as they had to contend with harassment from the Philippine Army which tried to prevent the families from immediately securing the bodies,” the group said in a statement Sunday.
“At one point, heavily-armed soldiers followed the family members and the human rights workers helping them, and even entered the funeral home where the bodies were interred,” it added.
Karapatan-Panay also reported that the remains of some of the NPA fighters bore other injuries, such as bruises, lacerations, and stab wounds.
The group said the injuries do not appear consistent with the AFP’s account that the rebels all died during the course of an “armed encounter.”
The conditions of the bodies suggest the possibility of torture, cruel treatment, and summary execution, it added.
“Such inhumane and degrading treatment of the bodies of deceased persons – whether civilian or enemy combatant – is wholly unacceptable, immoral, and contravenes international law and, most importantly, the Philippine government’s own commitments under an agreement entered into with the NDFP,” Karapatan-Panay said.
The Government of the Republic of the Philippines signed the Comprehensive Agreement on Respect for Human Rights and International Humanitarian Law (CARHRIHL) with the NDFP in 1998.
“The duty to dispose of the dead in a respectful manner, to facilitate the return of the remains of the deceased to their families, and to prevent the dead from being despoiled, as well as the prohibition against the mutilation of the bodies all form part of (IHL),” the group explained.
Many NDFP negotiators killed
The group pointed out that NDFP personnel such as Araneta-Bocala who are not part of the NPA fighting force and do not directly take part in hostilities are themselves protected from attack.
“An investigation is therefore warranted into the exact circumstances that led to the killings in Lambunao, Iloilo especially considering how unlikely it was for Concha Araneta-Bocala, the 74-year old NDFP consultant, to take part in hostilities,” the group said.
Karapatan said if Araneta-Bocala was indeed among the casualties, she would not be the first NDFP peace negotiator to be brutally executed.
KARAPATAN added it has documented numerous killings ranging from assassinations to staged ‘encounters’ where the victims were members of or linked to the NDFP.
They include the abduction and killing of NDFP consultant Rogelio Posadas by the Philippine Army in Negros Occidental in April 2023, the abduction of NDFP consultant Ariel Badiang in Bukidnon in February 2023, the killing of NDFP consultant Ericson Acosta and his companion in Negros Occidental in November 2022, the murder of NDFP consultant Julius Giron and his companions inside their home in Baguio City in March 2020, and the particularly gruesome stabbing and murder of NDFP consultant Randall Echanis and his companion in their apartment in Quezon City in August 2020,” the group said.
The group also cited the killing of seven NDFP staff members by government troops in San Jose, Antique in August 2018, as well as the killing of Concha Araneta-Bocala’s own husband, NDFP consultant Reynaldo Bocala and his companion by police operatives inside their house in May 2021.
Karapatan-Panay called for an investigation into all reports of human rights and humanitarian law violations, including possible violations that attended the deaths of NPA fighters and members of the NDFP in recent days. # (Raymund B. Villanueva)